Ok so, here's our situation. Our top dps is always the same 4 warlocks on every fight, each of them pushing about 1400-1700 dps. Since on phase 2 Gurtog kept targeting mages / priests / other stuff that he murders we decided to only bring our 4 warlocks as dps, the rest of the raid is made up of 3 prot pallies tanking gurtog and 18 holy paladins wearing tank gear.
We've got phase 2 pretty much down but always hit the enrage timer. We live like 1 minute into the enrage. But our warlocks still can't finish him.
What I'm asking is. How come our warlocks are failing us so badly?